Skip to Main Content
London Metropolitan University

Chemistry, Pharmaceutical Science, Pharmacology and Herbal Medicinal Science

Systematic review and systematic searching

Literature searching is the process of searching and retrieving information published on a specific topic. This gathering of information in your chosen topic prior to writing an essay, dissertation or carrying out a project will assist you in finding background information and case studies or examples to illustrate your argument. To do so, you need to be able to identify the sources that would enable you to find the information relevant to your subject. These include books, journals/newspapers, electronic resources, videos and websites (the Internet). Therefore, you need to acquire the skills of choosing these sources and the process of retrieving the information you need. You will not develop these skills overnight. You will acquire the necessary skills to search, select and evaluate the information you find with practice. You will need to familiarise yourself with the catalogue and electronic databases.

A systematic review is a type of literature review that is thorough and reproduceable.

Make use of the indexes of literature with the widest coverage available through London Met or for free, use as many keywords to describe your research topic as possible, and use subject headings where available.

Record your searches and results at each stage of the process and build your search up in steps. 

A systematic-type review that you will do as a student is done on a smaller scale than a published systematic review, so no need to include Google Scholar or grey literature sources.

Steps involved in writing a systematic review:

  1. Definition of the review question

  2. Writing, and approval, of the protocol

  3. Operation of the search strategy

  4. Study assessment

  5. Creation of meta-analyses

  6. Putting results of review into context

Please read The need for systematic reviews on nutrition and dietetics for details.


There is a practical guide to performing systematic reviews in a healthcare context provides a step-by-step approach for students and health professionals. Using free, open-source software to extract data and perform the necessary meta-analyses, this guide navigates the process of reviews, from study design and randomised controlled trials to interpreting results and reporting your findings.

Each chapter includes an overview, learning outcomes, and practice questions. Aimed particularly at those who do not have an extensive statistical background, it will help enable you to confidently perform high-quality systematic reviews.

Free download: https://bit.ly/438vzyU

What is the difference between a systematic review and a literature review?

Getting started - choosing databases:

You may want to include the following databases in your search. Most use three or more databases. See the A-Z of Library E-Resources for a description of each and to link through and start searching:

  • PubMed (includes MeSH - Medical Subject Headings)
  • The Cochrane Library (for RCTs and existing systematic reviews only, includes MeSH)
  • CINAHL Complete (includes CINAHL Subject Headings)
  • Web of Science
  • Trip Medical Database
  • SPORTDiscus
  • APA PsycINFO

Getting started - scoping searches:

Your first searches will NOT be systematic, but WILL help you to refine your research question, identify gaps in the research, and identify extra terminology for later searches. You may choose to scope only in one database rather than trying many.

The systematic searching and screening process (see the search recordings tab):

  • Scoping searches - see above.
  • Keyword searches - using synonyms or alternative keywords and building the search in stages, making sure you do Boolean AND and OR searches correctly until you've combined everything and got one set of search results.
  • MeSH/Subject Heading searches (where available) - carefully exploring and selecting appropriate subject headings and putting them together appropriately using Boolean techniques (as above), until you have one set of subject heading search results.
  • Combining final keyword results with final subject heading results using Boolean OR operator - this removes duplicates.
  • Applying filters that help you to find articles that meet your criteria - different filters available in different databases.
  • Exporting results from each database into a file or a reference management programme where you can see and remove any duplicates.
  • Screening by title and abstract and excluding items that clearly do not meet your criteria.
  • Identifying how to get access to the full articles - exclude any that you can't get at all (including through London Met, at the British Library, through the Sconul Access Scheme or via interlibrary loan requests).
  • Read full articles and exclude any that do not meet your criteria.

Recording your methods and results:

Record your methods and results at every stage of the process in preparation for writing up your methodology and record reasons for excluding studies. There are tools that can help you do this, such as saving searches with personal accounts in databases, or doing screenshots of your search history, or simply keeping a record in a Word document. Doing a simple Internet search for systematic review tools will show you the range of other tools available.

See the other resources section of this guide to find links to PRISMA for the PRISMA flow diagram.

To allow full functionality for this content, you need to accept cookies for this site.  Alternatively access here: PubMed Advanced Search.
To allow full functionality for this content, you need to accept cookies for this site.  Alternatively access here: PubMed MeSH Searching.
To allow full functionality for this content, you need to accept cookies for this site.  Alternatively access here: Cochrane keyword and MeSH searches.
To allow full functionality for this content, you need to accept cookies for this site.  Alternatively access here: Web of Science Keyword Searching.
  1. Too few results?
    • Choose broader terms
    • Use more synonyms combined with OR
    • Use fewer keywords combined with AND
    • Use a large interdisciplinary database
    • Use specialist sources
    • Use a 'citation pearl' as a starting point
      • Cited reference searching is also called snowballing, citation pearl searching, and forward- or backward-searching.
      • The process builds on an article or other document you already know is relevant to your study – a “citation pearl”.
      • You can look through the list of cited references to go backward in time and follow up on the sources the authors used.
      • Use the “citation pearl” to go forward in time using a citation index. 
  2. Too many results?
    • Ask more specific questions
    • Choose more specific terms
    • Use fewer synonyms combined with OR
    • Use a subject database
    • Use subject headings if available
    • Set limits
    • Sort results

Books

Books are still the main source of information as they give a comprehensive view on a particular subject. However, the disadvantage is that the books can be outdated.

 

It is very important to use the books given in your reading lists. You can also find books available on your topic using a keyword search in your catalogue. Furthermore, bibliographies given in books are useful for finding other books on your topic. Reading the summary or the blurb, or studying the contents list and the index of a textbook, will enable you to decide the relevance of this for your topic.

 

Catalogues are useful to find out what has been published in a particular subject, to find details of a book and also to find out the location of the particular book you want.

 

Books can be searched via

· the University Library Catalogue

· Jisc Library Hub Discover

· British Library Catalogue

Journals

A journal is a collection of articles written by scholars in an academic field, published at a regular interval - weekly, fortnightly, monthly, quarterly, biennially, or annually. The articles are peer-reviewed and have up-to-date and detailed information compared to that of books.

 

Journal articles are indexed and can be searched by subject, author, and title, and are available in electronic format (see electronic databases). Reading the abstracts (summaries) provided should enable you to decide whether it is relevant or not for your topic.

Magazines

A magazine is also like a journal, published at regular intervals, and contains articles by several contributors. However, the difference is that the articles are mainly geared toward the general public and are usually written by journalists. They are good for finding articles on current affairs and topical debates. 

Newspapers

Newspapers are also published at a regular interval, daily national papers and weekly local papers. They are a good source for current information about international, national, and local events. 

Grey literature

Materials that are not published through normal channels and therefore not available in a bookshop come under this category. Examples of such materials are theses, reports, and conference papers. 

Links to Electronic (online) Journals and Databases

You can access the electronic version of most of the journals we subscribe to via the Library Catalogue by following the hyperlink given on the journal record. You can also access the Electronic Databases: A-Z list via the Library Services page. You can also find a list of relevant Journals and Electronic Databases on your Subject Library Guide.

Using the Internet

Remember, anybody can publish material on the Internet, and there is no governing body in control of the quality of information that can be placed on the Internet. Therefore, it is important to evaluate what you find on the Internet. You must find out who is responsible for the document, what type of server that particular file is on, and where the file is registered. The UNIFORM RESOURCE LOCATOR (URL) is the unique address of any web document, and this can give you answers to all these questions.

Searching online

When you are searching online, including the catalogue, databases, and the Internet, use the same techniques. Two fundamental techniques of seeking information on the Internet are- SEARCHING & BROWSING

Searching

When you know what you want and need, you can locate specific information by entering a word/s or a phrase in a search box.

Browsing

When you follow a collection of hyperlinks (underlined text) through a set of web pages, containing lists of resources organised by subject. You browse a collection of links when you want to find out what is available on the Internet in your subject area.

Internet tools

Search Engines– should be used when you want something specific and need to be located quickly. E.g., looking for particular names of people or organisations. Files are collected and indexed by robots (machine intervention), e.g., GOOGLE 

Searching for anything online – i.e., the catalogue, journal databases, and the Internet follows the same principles.

 

Use of Boolean logic AND, OR to link keywords

  • AND -Links words or phrases that must both appear anywhere in the same document, no matter how close or far apart. E.g., searching for children AND television AND violence returns records containing all three words anywhere in the same document.
  • OR – links synonyms, alternative forms of expression, acronyms, e.g., colour OR color
  • KEYWORD searching - Note that the space between the keywords defaults to either OR logic or AND logic. Therefore, it is very important, before you start your search, to find out the default settings the search tools use by visiting the help file and the site.
  • Use of PHRASE – using quotes around phrases ensures results are restricted to exact matches. This is useful, especially when you are looking for a proper name or a known phrase. E.g., united nations, world health organisation.

 

Use of truncation

  • enables to retrieval of variations in one search term. This is useful when you are searching for a term with many possible endings, such as singular and plural versions
  • , e.g., child* retrieves child and children,
  • feminin* retrieves feminism, feminist, and feminine

 

Parentheses (Brackets)

  • AND operators should not be used inside (), whilst OR statements should be enclosed in ()
  • e.g. (single OR lone) AND parent*
  • “eating disorder” AND (anorexia OR bulimia)

 

Creating searches

  • Before embarking on a search, have a clear idea of the purpose of your search.
  • Define your search.
    • Best to plan your search strategy on paper first. Analyse your topic and write down the keywords that you are expecting to find in your search results. Use them as keywords in your search statement
    • Decide on the type of resources that you want to search
    • Write down the search statement, using the search techniques we have discussed above
    • Make records of search results. Take down the necessary details for referencing.

 

Finding information should be done in stages 

  • Analysing the question: before you start your research, read the question and decide what is required – what does it ask you to do? E.g., compare and contrast, evaluate.
  • Underline keywords, find their meanings and definitions, and also synonyms (alternative words)
  • Books – Look up in the index of textbooks
  • Specific Dictionaries – to define a word/phrase
  • Subject Handbooks - to find information on your field of study

It is important to find much information from books, especially given on the reading lists.

You need to have a good understanding of the topic relating to the question before you go on to the next step.

  • Brainstorm – write down what you have read and understood, in your language, about your topic. Now, you pick out the relevant keywords/phrases relating to the question.